András
Csejdy
Hope Dies Last
[...]* Tamás Sas: Presszó (Bar) * [...]
* Juli Sára: Apa gyoýz (Daddy Wins)
[...]
The cameraman Tamás Sas makes his debut as a director at this
festival. The basic idea of his film, Bar, is simple enough: the entire
movie is recorded from a fixed camera position. Everything we see in this
90-minute film takes place in the bar or in front of it, as seen through
the window. The scene is a typical Budapest locale and the story is a single-location
tale; the filmmakers took a serious risk in hoping that audiences, accustomed
to the visual variety in cinema language, would put up with a homogeneous
visual world throughout the film, and that a story-line and swift dialogue
delivered by good actors would be able to hold their attention.
It is a brave and risky undertaking, as there are not too many directors
who can present contemporary characters speaking in such an entertaining,
interesting and authentic manner--not to mention the fact that we are not
all that well provided with good actors, either. For this reason, the film
is a pleasant surprise. In watching Bar, we really feel that we are sitting
there, listening to the three girl friends describe what has happened to
them and witnessing a talkative TV editor picking them up, exploiting them
and ruining them in succession. From the dialogue, as well as from what
happens at neighbouring tables, an exciting and realistic tableau of what
is going on in the country right now is presented to us, and that alone
is a rare achievement.
Bar is an immaculately directed film, with some excellent acting and occasional
flashes of classical dramaturgy: an excellent period piece on the private
sphere.
[...]
I've left the amazing competition entry by a young woman in her early
twenties, Juli Sára, to the end. Daddy Wins, her diploma work, was
based on a short story by Mihály Kornis, one of the enfants terribles
of Hungarian writing. How is it possible to create magical realism from
home-made material? How is it possible to tell a chilling story about death
in the clichéd language of chansons? What does it mean to be a Jew
in Hungary? These are questions answered in the original story. What makes
the movie version different, and perhaps more powerful, is the unbelievable
confidence with which Juli Sára is able to get various prominent
Hungarian actors to produce mannerless, authentic and moving characters.
In forty immaculate minutes, the past fifty years of Hun gary's past have
been captured, which is an astounding achievement even from someone who
is suspected to be a prodigy.
Shot in black and white, Daddy Wins is a movie with complex characters
and figures; as a result of the absurd opening situation, the dead narrator
can speak about the most fundamental issues of life in a conversational
tone: "It is an outrage to die. You need no coffee anymore. You need
no cigarettes anymore. That is the good part of it. But never forget: 'Life
according to T. It is good.' "
We can be certain that we will be hearing more of and from Juli Sára.
András Csejdy
is a free-lance film critic and writer.